Should I use a variable ND or a set of fixed NDs?
Validated 13 November 2026
Applies to
- Line
- Filters
- Attribute
- Variable ND
Resolution
- 01
Ask whether the light changes during the take. A variable ND is set by rotating the front ring while the camera runs, so it covers a change in light inside a single shot. A fixed ND is one density for the whole setup.
- 02
Choose a fixed ND where a polarizer is also going on the lens. Tiffen states the reason and the remedy:
The Tiffen VND filter is made of two circular polarizing filters. Adding a third CP filter will cause cross polarization issues and is not recommended. If you wish to shoot with a ND filter and a CP filter at the same time, we recommend using a set stop value ND filter instead of a VND.
- 03
Choose a fixed ND where you are shooting wide and dense. Tiffen states the X Bar Effect happens with all variable ND filters at dark densities and wide focal lengths, and that the remedy is to lighten the density, zoom in, or both.
- 04
Test the variable ND on the widest lens you will use, before the shoot. Rotate through the full range on that lens and record the density at which the cross appears. That figure is your working limit for the day.
- 05
Size a fixed set against the exposure range you shoot. Tiffen's published fixed range runs .3, which is 1 stop, to 3.0, which is 10 stops.
- 06
Put the variable ND last if you stack anything with it. Tiffen advises against stacking a VND, and states that where you do, it goes on the outside because of the threads.
- 07
Note the warranty term for what you buy. Tiffen filters carry 10 years, and IR and IRND filters carry 1 year from the date of purchase.
Cause
Tiffen states that a variable ND is made of two circular polarizing filters, and that its density is set by rotating one against the other. One control therefore sets both the density and the orientation of the polarization, and the X Bar Effect appears when that pair is turned toward its dense end on a wide lens.
A fixed ND is a single density with no rotating element. Its density does not change while the camera runs, and no cross appears at any strength.